Turun kauppakorkeakoulun tieteenfilosofinen kerho

Tag: Sustainability

Reassembling the Firm for People and Planet?

TSElosophers’ meeting 19.10.2026

Participants:  Albrecht Becker, Niina Hakala, Annika Hasselblad, Samu Kantola, Anniina Kinnunen, Kari Lukka, Mia Salo, Milla Unkila, Kaisa Vuorio

Reading:

Unkila, Milla (2027). The future of firms in alternative economic systems. Draft for a book chapter in: Leadership for Biodiversity – Towards Nature-Respectful Futures. (Routledge) 

Background and summary of the article 

During our October meeting, we discussed the almost final draft of Milla Unkila’s forthcoming book chapter, ‘The Future of Firms in Alternative Economic Systems’. In this chapter, Milla explores how the nature of firms might change in economic systems no longer driven by the pursuit of growth and profit. By examining the different dimensions and mechanisms of economic systems and considering how the familiar components of business models might operate under different arrangements, she asks whether firms could use and maintain their capacity to organize collective action to serve the needs of people and the planet.

This time, our discussion took a slightly different form, as the author was one of our own TSElosophers. The meeting unfolded through a series of comments and reactions from fellow members, to which Milla offered further reflections. The following brings together some of the comments and questions raised during the meeting, from which several lines of thought emerged.

Discussion

TSElosophers found the chapter an inspiring invitation to rethink some of the sacrosanct assumptions of our economic system, particularly the imperative of economic growth and the faith in its ability to resolve the ecological crisis, as reflected in the so-far unfulfilled promises of green growth. Yet, our discussion soon turned from imagining alternative economic arrangements to the messy realities of what it would take to bring such visions into existence. Who exactly is the ‘we’ being called upon to stop confusing economic goals with the tools used to achieve them? What should be done differently, by whom, and how?

These concerns became more concrete as we considered the governance and managerial arrangements that shape how firms actually operate. After all, there are already various forms of organization and ownership. It was noted how even organizations without conventional shareholders are not free from the pressures and imperatives of the prevailing economic system. Nor would simply moving from private to public ownership necessarily resolve the organizational challenges of addressing complex geographically specific ecological and social issues. The possibility of nationalizing housing companies provided an interesting example: while public ownership might seem a way to address social needs and democratize organizing, it would not, in itself, guarantee better management or more equitable outcomes.

This brought us back to questions of institutions, regulation and legal arrangements, whose absence from the chapter was noted. What would democratic institutions look like in alternative economic systems? How should we understand the distinction between centralized and decentralized governance? By remaining largely at the level of economic theory and the theory of the firm, the chapter left open the question of where we might actually intervene to reconfigure the systems within which firms operate and form a critical node of. For instance, if corporate and contract law, including legal protections for investors, shape what firms can and cannot do, might zooming into these arrangements offer a more concrete way forward than simply calling for different organizational purposes or logics of value creation? In her comments Milla, however, noted that the possibilities of intervention were lacking more or less deliberately as one of the driving ideas of the chapter was to highlight the scale and scope of changes necessary for the firms to function within a non-growth oriented economy – the distance between what is theoretically logically possible and in practice doable is in her view somewhat impossible to span.

Finally, the chapter’s critique of money as a primary means of organizing economic life provoked both interest and critical questions. If we move beyond the primacy of financial value or money as a means of coordination and exchange, what would motivate actors with differing interests and values to work towards a common good? The Soviet Union was mentioned as a possible example of the difficulties of sustaining collective action in the absence of financial incentives. Does motivation to collaborate need extrinsic incentives or could human collaboration emerge as intrinsically driven process?

Underlying these different threads was a question about what drives human behaviour and how our values and relationships are formed in the first place. To what extent might economic assumptions about self-interested and greedy individuals themselves be performative, helping to produce the very behaviours they describe? And have these ideas become so influential precisely because they resonate with certain aspects of human behaviour? Such questions seemed difficult to address without considering the social fabric that connects us and shapes our values and actions.

Towards the end, we found ourselves returning to the familiar realization that we live in a world shaped by someone else’s visions and ideas, originating in other times and places, yet so deeply woven into our everyday lives that notions such as economic growth seem natural and inevitable. What, then, might be the felicity conditions for other visions of the firm and the economy to become equally real?

Known problems tackled with ecological realism?

TSElosophers meeting on 3 February 2025

Participants: Albrecht Becker, Annika Hasselblad, Samu Kantola, Erkki Lassila, Kari Lukka, Ari Nieminen, Mia Salo, Milla Unkila

Reading: Domination, Power, Supremacy: Confronting Anthropolitics with Ecological Realism

Toni Ruuska, Pasi Heikkurinen and Kristoffer Wilén, Sustainability 2020, 12, 2617; doi:10.3390/su12072617

Summary

Anthropocene is caused by anthropolitics – systems of power built on the notion of human supremacy that enable the domination of non-humans and a mass of humans by a smaller group of humans. The article traces the foundations and premises of anthropolitics grounded on a specific version of humanism, discusses the merits and deficits of post-humanist approaches as solutions to future social organizing, and introduces ecological realism as an alternative theoretical frame that could underpin the formulation of genuinely sustainable societies.

Our discussion

This was one of the articles that divided the Tselosophers into two camps. Many of us applauded the clear and understandable articulation of the complex past trajectories that have brought us to the brink (and over?) of the current environmental calamities and admired the courage of the scholars to not only weave together the many strands of the problems but also to take a step further and suggest future possibilities. Others, in turn, stated that the depiction of the problems was nothing new – after all, we have at least 50 years known that human actions are destroying the globe – and that at least some of the seven suggested solutions for future societies were questionable to the extent of some reading even as naïve, especially as the authors made no mention of how to reach the desired end states.

This point triggered discussion: indeed, there has been ample discussion of the root causes of the current problems. However, it is not the novel knowledge on any of the single themes outlined in the article that creates value but the drawing of the bigger picture, here labelled as anthropolitics, that is fresh. After all, the current scholarly mechanisms do not support integrative approaches, making it very difficult to understand the amalgamated mess of human choices responsible for the problems. The fans of the article also noted that while the issues have been pointed out, too few attempts have been made to paint possible images of the principles that could underpin future societies and the lack of any visions of the potential directions makes it impossible to move towards them – we would sorely need goals to try to figure out how to get there.

Of the seven suggested solutions, especially decentralization and detechnologization were contested. Considering the global scope of the problems, it was pondered whether a local turn would be a beneficial direction to address them. In terms of technology, some of us accepted that to stop the overshoot, we would need, first of all, to move away from our energy dependence, which would naturally lead to less available technology, whereas some others were more hopeful as regards technology being at least a part of some solutions.

A theme that spawned most discussion was the perception of human agency, especially as it relates to the question of whether we need to see humans as qualitatively different from other species to hold them responsible for their negative impacts or whether it is possible to detach responsibility from the concept of agency. The concern with the latter position is this: As we all accept that humans have no more value than other living beings, should we think that humans are similar to other animals to the extent where our agency – as understood to include responsibility – is not a unique feature, but our effects on the planet are merely a question of scope and scale? If so, that could leave a way out of the responsibility of us humans: We can always shrug and say that as we don’t blame other animals for exhibiting species-typical behavior, neither should we humans be blamed for our respective features. However, some of us do not want to leave that loophole and instead argue that while non-humans do have an equal value to humans, there is a qualitative difference in humans – that is, our ability to conscious intentionality – which has resulted, among other things, in our destructive actions. These TSElosophers believe that agency is a combination of responsibility and intentionality, not something that can be reduced to merely causing effects, which is something each human and non-human, living and non-living entity, in any case, is involved with.

There were several other themes mentioned but not dug deeply into, too. For example, we noted that while the authors discuss the conceptualization of human agency underpinning anthropolitics (e.g., will to power), they did not elaborate on a conceptualization of human agency that could underpin ecological realism and responsibility for the planet. Additionally, we pondered the distinction between the notion of hybridism when discussing post-humanism and parts vs. the whole when discussing ecological realism, wondering what precisely was the point of the authors for differentiating them. This contemplation led to a vivid discussion on the notion of agency in ANT (arguably one version of hybridism) and to what extent the principle of symmetry inherent in ANT helps deal with the question of responsibility for the effects actors produce.

Overall, this article proved a fruitful starting point for a rich discussion, and had the time not limited the discussion, it could have taken us to many additional directions now left unexplored.

© 2026 TSElosophers

Theme by Anders Noren — Up ↑